club asia
While many fans praised her bravery, a number of netizens voiced concerns that the issue was blown out of proportion, particularly regarding the extent of the alleged mistreatment.
On X, Hanni’s statements sparked a “war of words” between NewJeans and Illit fans. Rumors surfaced that Illit was involved in the alleged bullying, prompting Illit’s agency Belift Lab to formally deny any involvement.
Despite it, tensions between the fandoms escalated, with insults traded online.
READ: Are you a toxic concertgoer?
the most ridiculous thing is that who really deserved to be in the national assembly talking about bullying and harassment workplace were illit and le sserafim who suffer to this day with defamations spread by min heejin. the same person hanni supports while playing the victim https://t.co/2v6vcO41dP
— 🔄 (@ktae0096) October 15, 2024
The most disgusting statement from NewJeans’ Hanni today was when she said, “I came here for the sake of my juniors.” Is she unaware of the terrible things she has done to ILLIT? pic.twitter.com/2kAlQJNFdw
— MHJ translation (@jaemgwan) October 15, 2024
Hanni has nothing to complain about, so her speech did nothing for anyone who is actually struggling with bullying or harassment. Complaining about being ignored, especially with no proof, closes the door on legitimate cases. Plus, her accusations spawned hate/abuse to Illit & Co
— Theo67 (@glomad67) October 16, 2024
Another post was far more scathing, claiming that Hanni had “ruined her group’s career for good” by bringing the issue to light.
Some netizens also voiced strong doubts about the severity of Hanni’s claims, implying that while she may feel mistreated, other idols face far worse treatment but garner less attention from the public and media.
Bts WERE ignored. By the entire kindustry, were bullied, insulted and looked down upon but they never complained about it like hanni did. The fukn audacity u have to compare bts’s abuse to hanni being ignored even tho illit and their staff have every right to ignore her. https://t.co/zOHOsc5JUD
— Hikari⁷~ᴴᵃᵖᵖʸ (@btsmelodiam) October 10, 2024
On Reddit, where discussions are more detailed, a netizen pointed out that Hanni’s claims seemed vague and lacked substantial evidence.
The user stated, “Everything else is just sort of vague statements with no proof or context, is about not being greeted properly but there are several videos of the nj girls outright ignoring their peers.” The user further expresses discomfort with Hanni’s demeanor during the assembly, adding, “It’s being reframed as her being a ‘girl boss’ out to defeat the evil HYBE, which feels uncomfortable given the serious nature of the issues at hand.”
Screenshot from Unpopular Kpop Opinions/Reddit
Despite the mixed reactions from netizens, Hanni’s parliamentary testimony ignites a crucial conversation about workplace bullying within the K-pop industry, highlighting the struggles idols face beyond the glitz and glamor.
The conversation she sparked also calls for a reassessment of the industry’s treatment of idols, emphasizing the need for improved mental health support and recognition of their rights. By bringing these issues to lightclub asia, Hanni advocates for a culture where idols can thrive not just as performers but also as individuals deserving of respect and support.